The Grammy Awards returned to New York City this year — and, appropriately, threw a dash of Broadway into the mix.
LuPone, 68, reprised her 1981 Grammys performance of the showstopper “Don’t Cry For Me Argentina” from Evita, while the Dear Evan Hansen star, 24, performed the classic “Somewhere (There’s a Place For Us)” from West Side Story in a special Broadway tribute honoring Andrew Lloyd Webber and Leonard Bernstein’s music.
Be sure to check out PEOPLE’s full Grammys coverage to get the latest news on music’s big night.
That’s not Platt’s only reason to celebrate the evening — the Dear Evan Hansen cast recording took home the 2018 Grammy for best musical theater album, given out at the pre-show.
RELATED VIDEO: Here’s the List of Nominees for the 2018 Grammy Awards
The 60th annual Grammy Awards, hosted by James Corden, were broadcast live on CBS from Madison Square Garden in New York City.