Entertainment Music Katy Perry Left Stunned by '90 Day Fiancé' Star Evelyn Cormier During 'American Idol' Auditions Perry called the reality TV star "one of my favorite voices I've ever heard in my life" By Jordan Runtagh Jordan Runtagh Twitter Jordan Runtagh is an Executive Podcast Producer at iHeartRadio, where he hosts a slate of pop culture shows including Too Much Information, Inside the Studio, Off the Record and Rivals: Music's Greatest Feuds. Previously, he served as a Music Editor at PEOPLE and VH1.com. He's written about art and entertainment for more than a decade, regularly contributing to outlets like Rolling Stone and Entertainment Weekly, and appearing as a guest on radio and television. Over the course of his career, he's profiled the surviving Beatles, Brian Wilson, Aretha Franklin, Roger Waters, David Byrne, Pete Townshend, Debbie Harry, Quincy Jones, Brian May, Jerry Lee Lewis, James Taylor and many more. A graduate of NYU's Tisch School of the Arts, he lives in Brooklyn, where he can be found DJing '60s soul records. People Editorial Guidelines Published on March 18, 2019 12:30 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Katy Perry has a new “favorite voice” — and she’s already a familiar face on reality TV. 90 Day Fiancé star Evelyn Cormier left the pop chart-topper stunned following her performance during the audition round of American Idol in the episode that aired Sunday night. Performing an acoustic rendition of Chris Isaak’s 1989 hit “Wicked Games,” Cormier earned kind words from fellow Idol judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. But it was Perry, 34, who seemed particularly blown away by her vocals, proclaiming her “one of my favorite voices I’ve ever heard in my life” as the last notes faded away. “Evelyn, pick the right songs,” she continued. “You are my favorite voice.” Richie also had lots of praise for the talented 19-year-old. “You have a sound that’s yours. I love the air. I don’t know what you’re doing, but whatever it is it’s an absolutely amazing identity.” ABC/Nicole Rivelli He added, “I’m thrilled that we have you. [Your voice] is something that we want to showcase. It’s something that we want to show off.” Before they realized her reality star status, the trio of judges mused on which actress Cormier most resembled. Perry suggested Anne Hathaway, but Bryan, 42, was getting strong Rachel McAdams vibes — which worked out great because Cormier cited The Notebook as her favorite movie! Evelyn Cormier on 90 Day Fiancé with her new now-husband David Vázquez Zermeño. Cormier’s husband — and 90 Day Fiancé costar — David Vázquez Zermeño was nearby, cheering her on from the waiting area. On Sunday he posted a video of her audition to Instagram along with some thrilling news: she’s going to Hollywood! Cormier first revealed that she tried out for the show in an Instagram post shared back in December. 90 Day Fiancé Star Evelyn Cormier Reveals She Will Compete in the New Season of American Idol “**Just gunna drop this here** ” she captioned a photo of herself in a hooded jacket, clutching a hot beverage with an Idol badge on her chest.