The Angry Birds Movie flies into theaters May 20

By Chancellor Agard
Updated March 10, 2016 09:15 AM
Credit: Courtesy Sony

Is the Easter Bunny a girl or boy? The Hatchlings may have the answer.

In this exclusive video, the adorable baby birds from The Angry Birds Movie, who charmed you with their rendition of “Deck the Halls,” return to spread some Easter cheer – and of course, it’s just as hilarious as you’d expect.

This time around, the producers asked the young children voicing the birds to sing an Easter classic, but unfortunately, none of them knew any Easter carols.

“We suggested they share their favorite Easter memories instead,” producer John Cohen tells PEOPLE. “We didn’t expect the memories to be this weird.”

While one little one recalls getting lice on the holiday, another tries to invent an Easter song on the spot. However, an argument breaks out when the lyrics suggest the Easter Bunny is a girl. Naturally, the disagreement ends when the Hatchling insisting it’s a boy is sent flying off the screen.

The Angry Birds Movie – with featured voices including Jason Sudeikis, Josh Gad, Danny McBride, Bill Hader, Maya Rudolph, and many more – flies into theaters May 20.