The questions involved a sex swing, going commando and a pirate costume

By Michele Corriston
Updated June 29, 2015 10:45 PM
Advertisement
Credit: Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic

Ever play two truths and a lie? “Manganiello or Mangan-Hell No” is kind of like that, except it’s all about a sultry Magic Mike star.

Joe Manganiello, PEOPLE’s reigning Hottest Bachelor (but not for long, thanks to fiancée Sofia Vergara), stopped by The Talk on Monday to play the game with the hosts, who each had to determine whether the personal details he revealed to them were fact or fiction.

Let’s just say the questions involved a sex swing, going commando and a pirate costume.

Watch the video above to see whether the ladies won.

One thing that we know to be true? His love for Vergara, 42.

“I knew I was going to marry her. Even as early as the filming of Magic Mike XXL in September,” Manganiello, 38, told PEOPLE. “I knew I was going to propose to her. I was planning it while we were filming.”

Magic Mike XXL hits theaters Wednesday, and The Talk airs weekdays at 2 p.m. ET on CBS.

For much more from Manganiello, Channing Tatum and the rest of the cast (plus an exclusive cast shot!), pick up this week’s issue of PEOPLE, on newsstands now