The two split Wednesday after over a year of dating, though they were last seen getting cozy a week and a half ago at the 2017 Governors Awards.
Although Lawrence, 27, and Aronofsky, 48, did not pose together on the red carpet, the couple sat together at a table and appeared to be in good spirits during the event. Both seemed happy, but kept their relationship low key, choosing not to pack on the PDA.
The Oscar-winning actress and the director only stepped out on a carpet together at the New York premiere of mother! where they stayed close and smiled for the cameras.
The two made their public debut for the Venice Film Festival photocall of mother! where they posed with Lawrence’s costars in the film, Javier Bardem and Michelle Pfeiffer. The occasion marked the first time the couple stepped out for a public event.
The outing came as Aronofsky and Lawrence had been getting more serious a year into their relationship. A source told PEOPLE at the time the couple had a lot in common and they made a good pair.
“They have a very good relationship that is serious in the sense that they are on the same wavelength,” a source close to Lawrence said. “They respect each other in the most important ways and have many of the same interests. She is comfortable with him and in awe of his brilliance and talent.”
The actress first talked about the relationship after a year of staying mum in an interview with Vogue. Lawrence shared that she was immediately drawn to the director after meeting on the set of the film.
“We had energy,” she said. “I had energy for him. I don’t know how he felt about me.”
Lawrence added, “I’ve been in relationships before where I am just confused. And I’m never confused with him.”
The two began dating in September shortly after wrapping mother!, and their relationship continued to blossom despite their 22-year age difference.
“Jennifer is comfortable with an older guy because she is mature and focused,” a source previously told PEOPLE.
RELATED VIDEO: Darren Aronofsky Raves About Jennifer Lawrence’s Acting in New Film ‘Mother!’
According to another source, the two kept a low profile when stepping out in New York City, where they were spotted on movie dates and casual strolls.
“They are very sweet together and seem happy,” the source said at the time. “They hold hands. They keep to themselves and don’t seem to want a lot of attention.”
The Oscar winner was first spotted dining with the Brooklyn native in New York City in August 2016. They then spent time in Los Angeles in October, where they had an intimate dinner with her close friends at the Commissary restaurant at The Line Hotel. In November, they joined forces to encourage college students to get out and vote.
As 2016 came to a close, the couple went for a romantic walk through New York City’s Central Park on New Year’s Eve with the her beloved pooch Pippi.
An insider told PEOPLE that Lawrence was happy to be dating someone who doesn’t attract the spotlight like some of her past boyfriends, such as Coldplay frontman Chris Martin.
“She struggled when she dated Chris and seemed very stressed out,” the source said of the publicity that comes with dating the singer. “With Darren, it will probably be different. He does not attract attention like Chris does.”
The source added that like Lawrence, the director “is very low-key.”
“He does not seem like a person who enjoys being a celebrity. Jennifer is the same,” said the insider.
At the same time, an industry source said Lawrence dating in Hollywood was a good move for her.
“Jen is a serious actress and being around another person in the business who is intense about what he does has been good for her,” said the source. “I don’t know how far it will go but as of now they are a really good match, two talented people who love their work and are respected for it.”
The director was previously in a nine-year relationship with actress Rachel Weisz (the two have a son, 10-year-old Henry), before they broke up in 2010, and Weisz moved on to marry her Dream House costar Daniel Craig.