Human Interest Texas Mom Welcomes 2 Babies Conceived 1 Week Apart in Extremely Rare Phenomenon "Everyone in the room was in shock," Cara Winhold said of finding out she wasn't just having one baby, but two By Charmaine Patterson Charmaine Patterson Digital News Writer, PEOPLE People Editorial Guidelines Published on June 29, 2022 12:15 AM Share Tweet Pin Email Photo: Cara Winhold A Fort Worth, Texas, mom is celebrating being a mom of three after she welcomed twin boys in quite the unusual way. Cara Winhold had already suffered three miscarriages when she became pregnant last spring. So when she arrived at a five-week appointment to check on what she believed was one fetus in April 2021, she was extra cautious. "I hated that I felt that way," Winhold, 31, told TODAY Parents in a feature published on Monday. "I wanted to be optimistic." "The losses really took a toll on us," she said of her previous miscarriages. S.C. Man Wins $100K From Lottery by Using Strategy He Saw on TLC's Lottery Changed My Life Cara Winhold Still, when a sonographer couldn't find a heartbeat at her initial appointment, Winhold told the outlet, "It was still early. I knew I couldn't lose hope. It's not uncommon to not see a heartbeat at five weeks." Two weeks passed before the math teacher and her husband Blake's next appointment. By then, Winhold confessed to TODAY that she was "petrified," adding: "My blood pressure must have been so high. I remember sitting in the doctor's office shaking." Her emotions went from nervous to elated as she got the surprise of a lifetime: a healthy heartbeat was discovered for one baby, along with a second baby who wasn't there before, she said. Cara Winhold Sisters Feel Joy 'Like 5-Year-Olds' in First Meeting After 56 Years of Not Knowing the Other Existed "Everyone in the room was in shock," Winhold recalled to TODAY. The rare incident is known as superfetation, which occurs when an egg is released from a woman's ovary after she may be pregnant already, and implants alongside the first embryo in the uterus some time later. She told the outlet that her OBGYN suspects she conceived the babies one week apart. RELATED VIDEO: Lizzie McGuire Fan's Unusual Wedding Vows to His Now Husband Go Viral 'Really Captured Our Love' On Oct. 25, 2021, the couple, who also share 3-year-old son Wyatt, welcomed boys Colson and Cayden. The "older" twin Colson weighed 6 pounds, 5 ounces; and Cayden was born at 4 pounds, 9 ounces. Winhold also posts proud boy-mom moments with her twins and Wyatt on her TikTok page @mommawinhold, where she told her shocking story of welcoming the twins. Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. "I couldn't talk, I was crying, I was shaking, I was excited, I was really confused. My husband didn't talk at all, didn't know what to say," she said of her and her husband's initial reaction.