Drew Scott and new fiancé Linda Phan are getting crafty for Christmas!

Although the Property Brothers star, 38, and Phan, 31, travel the U.S. and Canada together for Drew and twin brother Jonathan’s many hit HGTV shows and other business ventures (like their book and Scott Living collection), it’s not all work for the newly engaged couple. Both often share snaps of the two taking cooking classes, watching basketball games and putting on a particular favorite holiday past time.

“Linda and I have a holiday tradition we call ‘Linda & Drew’s Build and Bake,’” Drew tells PEOPLE. “Linda is the crafting queen, so we like to build holiday-inspired crafts and bake Christmas-themed desserts.”

With Drew’s surprise proposal and the whole family’s upcoming trip to Hawaii, Drew and Phan haven’t posted any Build and Bake videos yet this year, but their Christmas concoctions (and admittedly a few crafting blunders) from last season’s set are the gifts that keep on giving.

Here, the two get involved in a blindfolded present-wrapping challenge, where Phan pulls out some pretty clever stops to take home the win. Although she uses some sneaky tactics to beat out her fiancé, the cookie gift tags she whips up after will certainly make up for her sly moves.

While the Brothers have plenty of holiday traditions (including a few gag gifts!), this festive fun is definitely the most aww-worthy. For more of Phan and Drew’s sweet series, visit his Facebook page here.