January 08, 2016 11:05 AM

India Earl

When Witney Carson decided she wanted a “winter wonderland” wedding, that meant the cake needed to fit the theme too.

“I wanted it to be simple with an ivory, kind of naked frosting,” the Dancing with the Stars pro, 22, tells PEOPLE of the cake served at the celebration of her nuptials to her high school sweetheart Carson McAllister on New Years Day.

RELATED: PHOTOS: See the Ultimate Celebrity Wedding Cakes

In addition to the Sugar Kisses cake, which was topped with seasonal berries and figs, guests were also treated to a candy bar. And a sign that read “All you need is love & a cupcake” enticed them to enjoy a plethora of mini cupcakes ranging from red velvet to vanilla to chocolate grasshopper.

India Earl

The sweets capped off a delicious meal prepared by State Street Feed and Supply of Lindon, Utah.

India Earl

India Earl

India Earl

“What we really wanted was for everyone to feel like they were enjoying a meal with family,” says Carson, whose wedding is featured in the current issue of PEOPLE. “So we wanted to serve warm comfort food that everyone would like and enjoy. We wanted them to feel at home.”

RELATED: See Sofia Vergara and Joe Manganiello’s Gorgeous Five-Tier, Floral Wedding Cake

– Patrick Gomez, @PatrickGomezLA

You May Like

EDIT POST