Lifestyle Food Trader Joe's Debuts 'Everything But the Leftovers' Seasoning for the Holidays This will make anything taste like Thanksgiving stuffing. By Mary Honkus Published on October 13, 2020 02:54 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Photo: mssochic/ instagram Trader Joe's Everything But the Bagel seasoning was its most popular item in 2019, and now they're introducing a new "everything" spice blend that is perfect for Thanksgiving. Everything But the Leftovers seasoning blend was recently spotted at the grocery chain by the Instagram account @Traderjoeslist. The blend is made up of classic Thanksgiving stuffing herbs like sage, rosemary, thyme, and parsley. In the latest episode of Trader Joe's "Inside TJ's" podcast, the Vice President of Marketing at the company, Matt Sloan, talks about the new "magic powder to make everything taste like Thanksgiving leftovers." Turkey Dinner-Flavored Candy Corn Is Now Available at Walgreens (Yes, Really) "To me, it tastes like the archetypal flavor of stuffing," Sloan says. He goes on to suggest various ways of using the blend — like sprinkling it over popcorn, mashed potatoes, or even stuffing "if you wanted your stuffing to taste that much more like stuffing." Sloan also jokes about keeping it on the Turkey Day table, "because sometimes family or friends bring over a dish that needs a little help." These Are the Most Popular Trader Joe's Items of 2019, According to Customers Last year, the Everything But the Bagel Seasoning was so popular that it knocked Mandarin Orange Chicken out of first place for most-purchased Trader Joe's item for the first time in three years.