Lifestyle Food We Tasted (and Graded) Every Crazy New Oreo Flavor See how these new cookies stack up (lol, get it?) to the original By Maria Yagoda Published on September 29, 2015 12:00 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Trending Videos 01 of 12 STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE Courtesy Oreo Concept: Fresh, fun and flirtyGrade: A-Tasting notes: A scent that would fill the Sistine Chapel accompanied by a delightfully sweet flavor that actually matches the concept 02 of 12 FILLED CUPCAKE Courtesy Nabisco Concept: Good idea, and at least it's not another riff on a cake flavorGrade: BTasting notes: Chocolatey, yes. Cremey, yes. But filled cupcake-y? It's not quite the Hostess with the mostest. 03 of 12 BROWNIE BATTER COURTESY OREO Concept: On pointGrade: B+Tasting notes: Decadent, rich, thick, lush 04 of 12 COTTON CANDY COURTESY OREO Concept: Whyyyy though?Grade: CTasting notes: Sweet, cotton-candy-y, cloying 05 of 12 RED VELVET COURTESY OREO Concept: HELL YESGrade: BTasting notes: Indulgent and sweet, but doesn't taste much like red velvet 06 of 12 TOASTED COCONUT COURTESY OREO Concept: We're into itGrade: B-Tasting notes: Very sweet, not much coconut, but lots of vanilla 07 of 12 KEY LIME PIE COURTESY OREO Concept: Citrus in an Oreo? I don't know about this.Grade: B+Tasting notes: Yummy Graham cracker cookie, disconcerting green color, nice/mellow flavor 08 of 12 OREO THINS COURTESY OREO Concept: Why mess with such a perfect shape?Grade: A+Tasting notes: Crispy, light, amazing, delicious 09 of 12 PUMPKIN SPICE COURTESY OREO Concept: Wait, pumpkin spice is still a thing?Grade: A-Tasting notes: Sweet, subtle, cinnamon-y, addictive 10 of 12 COOKIE DOUGH COURTESY OREO Concept: DREAMS COME TRUE.Grade: B+Tasting notes: Chocolatey, caramel-y, complex, but not quite cookie dough-y 11 of 12 MARSHMALLOW CRISPY COURTESY OREO Concept: Oh yes.Grade: C+Tasting notes: Far too sweet…but also delicious 12 of 12 S'MORES COURTESY OREO Concept: BrilliantGrade: ATasting notes: Yummy – and better than actual s'mores