We tried the country singer's new spirit and the results were pretty awesome
Credit: Backstage Whiskey

What It Is: Darius Rucker’s new Backstage Southern Whiskey

Who Tried It: Rennie Dyball, Senior News Editor

Why We Tried It: Um … why wouldn’t we?

Level of Difficulty: 0

When Darius Rucker was just starting out as a solo country artist, I was invited to attend a very small show he was putting on in N.Y.C. Maybe 200 fans, tops. If that wasn’t special enough, my husband John and I went backstage to meet “D” and join the ceremonial group whiskey shot with him and his band to kick off the show. It’s a longstanding tradition for Rucker (also the frontman for Hootie & the Blowfish, who penned a song titled “Whiskey and You,” it’s worth noting) to bring good luck for each show. I never forgot his congeniality and that fantastic, intimate performance in the city.

So when I had the chance to sample Rucker’s Backstage Whiskey and review it for PEOPLE, I jumped at the chance. There was just one problem: What do I know about whiskey? My experience with the spirit is pretty much limited to when Jack Daniel’s shows up at tailgates and ill-advised late-night shots.

Luckily, my husband John knows his way around the whiskey section of the liquor store a whole lot better than I do. What follows is our tasting session. Also known as: Hot date night at the kitchen counter after the kids are in bed.

Opening the bottle and smelling for the “notes” (we did a wine tour in Sonoma years ago and it ruined us forever) …

John: A little bit of licorice I think, which is a little strange.

Rennie: A little spicy. And fire.

John: No! Like moonshine.

Rennie: I think it smells like fire … Okay, now I think it smells nice. Maybe a little cinnamon.

John: Sure. Cinnamon.

Rennie: You don’t get the cinnamon?

John: No.

Rennie: It smells smoky right? Smoky, cinnamon, maybe a little licorice.

John: I’m telling you, I get a tiny bit of licorice.

Credit: Rennie Dyball

Tasting …

Rennie: I like it. Tastes way better than it smells.

John: Oh! Little bit of honey.

Rennie: (Rolls eyes but tries again) Actually, yeah!

John: There’s smokiness, there’s honey …

Rennie: (totally joking now) Cloves …

John: Yeah!

Rennie: Really? I was just saying random things.

John: No, that’s the smell that I was looking for!

Rennie: Oh, okay.

John: Let’s see what happens when we add an ice cube because that usually changes it.

(An ice cube is added to each glass)

Rennie: What are you getting?

John: See how it changes it?

Rennie: Not really. I like it better without the ice.

John: I get more of an oaky taste with the ice added.

Rennie: I think I’m a little drunk.

Enjoying the Backstage Whiskey and the swag that came with it (yes, I am actually wearing the “backstage pass”)
| Credit: Rennie Dyball

WATCH: You’ve Got to Hear Darius Rucker’s Forrest Gump Impression

Final thoughts from John…

“I like the bottle. There’s nothing fancy about it, and it reminds me a little bit of a Buffalo Trace bottle, which makes me happy because I like Buffalo Trace. It’s a cork top but it’s a plastic cork. I don’t know if that has any impact on how awesome the whiskey is.”

Want the ultimate dish on the latest celebrity food news, plus exclusive recipes, videos and more? Click here to subscribe to the People Food newsletter.

“Looking at the color, it’s definitely a darker whiskey and that makes me excited. Because a darker whiskey, there’s more joy in it. I think it’s a deeper brown with a little touch of red in it. If you pour this right next to a Jack Daniel’s, you can see this one is much darker. It tastes good neat, and even better with a little ice.”

Credit: Rennie Dyball

The verdict: From a man who knows his whiskey, this one is a hit. And from a woman whose first choice in adult beverages is typically Chardonnay, Backstage Whiskey is definitely worth a try. Even if nothing will top drinking it with Rucker himself.

Backstage Whiskey is available now ($28.99) in South Carolina and Tennessee and will soon be rolling out nationwide. Rucker’s bourbon brand, Forbidden, is in the works next.