Judge Denies Women's Request for Restraining Order Against L.A. Dodgers' Trevor Bauer

Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Trevor Bauer has been accused of sexual assault by two women

Trevor Bauer
Trevor Bauer. Photo: Rob Tringali/Getty

A California judge denied a 5-year restraining order request from a woman who has accused Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Trevor Bauer of sexual assault.

In addition to the denial, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Dianna Gould-Saltman dissolved the woman's temporary restraining order, PEOPLE confirms.

The woman, a 27-year-old from San Diego, has alleged that Bauer choked her unconscious while they were having sex and then punched her without consent on the second of two intimate encounters. She sought to extend her temporary restraining and have Bauer, 30, enter a 52-week battery program, according to reports.

They spent time together at Bauer's home on two separate occasions, in April and May, and after the second encounter, according to the Los Angeles Times, the woman sought medical care and alleged that the baseball star had assaulted her during sex.

The accuser testified during the hearing, which began Monday.

"I did not consent to bruises all over my body that sent me to the hospital and having that done to me while I was unconscious," the woman told the court, per a transcript obtained by PEOPLE.

On Thursday, Judge Gould-Saltman said, "The injuries as shown in the photographs are terrible," the transcript shows.

However, the judge said she believed Bauer did not do anything the woman didn't consent to.

"If she set limits and he exceeded them, this case would've been clear. But she set limits without considering all the consequences, and respondent did not exceed limits that the petitioner set," the judge said.

Trevor Bauer
Trevor Bauer. Katelyn Mulcahy/Getty

Shawn Holley, one of Bauer's attorneys, said in a statement outside of court, "We are grateful to the Los Angeles Superior Court for denying the request for a permanent restraining order and dissolving the temporary restraining order against Mr. Bauer today."

Lisa Helfend Meyer, one of the attorneys representing the woman, tells PEOPLE in a statement, "While our client is disappointed about the judge's ruling, she is hopeful that Mr. Bauer will voluntarily seek the help he needs to make sure that no other woman in a dating relationship with him suffers the same traumatic fate that she did. That is why she was willing to come forward and endure the victim-blaming from Mr. Bauer that she knew would inevitably result. Keeping not only herself but also other women safe from the hands of this troubled man has always been a priority -- and will continue to be so."

On Thursday, Bauer was called to the witness stand and invoked his Fifth Amendment right to not incriminate himself.

The judge stated her decision was based on evidence she believed showed the roughness of their sexual encounter was consensual. "We consider in a sexual encounter that when a woman says no she should be believed," Gould-Saltman said, per the transcript. "So, what should we do when she says yes?"

The judge also said that in communication with Bauer, the woman "was not ambiguous about wanting rough sex in the parties' first encounter, and wanting rougher sex in the second encounter."

However, Helfend Meyer told the judge, "The evidence has shown [the woman] was sexually and physically assaulted by Trevor Bauer — that this was not rough sex between two consenting adults. A person in her right mind would never have consented to what Trevor had done to her."

Bauer's attorney Holley told the judge, "I'm sure it was painful and unpleasant for her. And it is unfortunate. But she asked for these things" and cited text messages where the woman allegedly said, "Give me all the pain."

"She wonders if it is her fault and she is right to wonder that," Holley said during the hearing.

Helfend Meyer called Bauer a "monster" in her closing arguments adding, "Whatever happens, [the woman] has revealed who Trevor Bauer truly is for all the world to see. Hopefully, he will get help and not do this in the future under the guise of rough sex."

Bauer Under Police Investigation in California

In July, it was revealed the baseball player is under police investigation for an alleged assault involving the woman who testified this week.

The accuser obtained a temporary protective order against Bauer in June under the Domestic Violence Prevention Act, one of her attorneys Marc Garelick, said at the time. In a statement provided to PEOPLE, Garelick claimed the woman "suffered severe physical and emotional pain" as a result of the alleged assault.

In a separate statement to PEOPLE, Bauer's agent denied the allegation against the athlete and claimed that the assault claim was derived from a "brief and wholly consensual sexual relationship" that began in April.

Ohio Woman Also Accused Bauer of Assault

Earlier this month, news surfaced that a second woman, who is from Ohio, had accused Bauer of sexual assault in 2020.

According to The Washington Post, the athlete allegedly sent the woman a text message saying he doesn't "feel like spending time in jail for killing someone," adding in another text, "And that's what would happen if I saw you again." The messages, the woman's lawyers said, made her obtain the order of protection.

A police report obtained by The Post says that the woman attempted to show authorities photographs of her injuries in 2017, but was instead arrested for underage drinking. The outlet obtained photos showing bruises on the woman's face, as well as blood in her eyes. Per The Post, the police report did not say whether or not the woman's allegations were looked into.

In a social media statement released on Saturday, Bauer broke his silence regarding the Ohio woman and accused The Post of making a "false narrative."

"Despite my representatives providing a wealth of contradictory evidence, documents, statements, and background information showing the pattern of disturbing behavior by this woman and her attorneys, The Washington Post opted to ignore much of this information and to run a salacious story disseminating defamatory statements, false information, and baseless allegations," he wrote.

Bauer also said that the woman attempted to "extort me for millions of dollars last year in exchange for her not coming forward with false claims."

Fetterolf and Bauer's other agent, Rachel Luba, shared their own statement as well.

In it, the pair said that Bauer and the woman were in an "on-and-off" consensual relationship between 2016 and 2019 and that she continued to go after him, even filing a "bogus protection petition" while "demanding $3.4 million for her to 'remain silent.'"

In a statement to The Post, the pair also called the allegations of abuse "categorically false."

Bauer's paid leave from the Dodgers was extended on Thursday until Aug. 27 amid his legal trouble, according to ESPN.

If you or someone you know has been sexually assaulted, please contact the National Sexual Assault Hotline at 1-800-656-HOPE (4673) or go to rainn.org.

Related Articles