After the women found out about each other, they began speaking with authorities

By Greg Hanlon
February 15, 2021 11:55 AM
Joseph L. Davis
Joseph L. Davis
| Credit: Volusia Sherriff's Office/ Facebook

A Florida man is accused of proposing to a woman using the engagement ring and wedding band he stole from another woman he was dating.

According to a release from the Volusia Sheriff's Office, Joseph L. Davis, 48, allegedly used the name "Joe Brown" with one of the women and "Marcus Brown" with the other. Davis is currently at large and wanted on theft charges, the release states.

The release alleges one girlfriend discovered he was engaged to someone else, and when she checked the fiancée's Facebook page, she noticed the woman was wearing a wedding band and engagement ring that were identical to the ones she had been given from a previous marriage.

When the girlfriend checked her jewelry box, she allegedly discovered both rings were missing along with other jewelry, amounting to about $6,270 in value, the release states.

According to the release, the girlfriend allegedly confronted Davis about the missing jewelry and also communicated with the fiancée, which enabled her to get some of her belongings back. With their relationships with Davis now over, the two women began cooperating with authorities, the release states.

Joseph L. Davis
Joseph L. Davis
| Credit: Volusia Sherriff's Office/ Facebook

Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for PEOPLE's free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.

According to the release, the fiancée alleged Davis stole from her and also lied to her, including taking her to the girlfriend's house while claiming it was his and asking her to move in with her. The fiancée told authorities that she had disassembled her furniture and packed up her apartment before Davis told her the deal had fallen through.

Both women met Davis on OKCupid and neither knew his real name, the release states. Authorities were able to identify him after the fiancée remembered the name and address of a niece Davis had in North Carolina.

Authorities say that once they identified Davis, they discovered he had a criminal record in both Oregon and North Carolina, as well as an arrest warrant out of Oregon in connection with an alleged hit and run crash with injuries.

Anyone with information about Davis' whereabouts is asked to contact the Volusia Sheriff's Office at 386-668-3830 and ask for Detective Wheeler. Those who want to remain anonymous and qualify for a potential cash reward can contact Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida at 888-277-TIPS, or via the P3 Tips app.