Crime Teen Football Star Is Fatally Shot on Date with Girlfriend: 'Last Word He Said to Me Was 'Help'' Police are still searching for a motive in the fatal shooting of 17-year-old high school football star Elijah DeWitt By KC Baker Published on October 12, 2022 01:43 PM Share Tweet Pin Email A teenage date night turned into a tragedy when a Georgia high school football star was fatally shot in a restaurant parking lot. "I run over to Elijah, and he's on the ground, and I go right over to him, and he mouths to me — the last word he said to me was 'help,'" victim Elijah DeWitt's longtime girlfriend, Bailey Reidling, told Fox News Digital. A standout senior wide receiver on the Jefferson High School football team, DeWitt and Reidling started dating five years ago, Fox News Digital reports. On Oct. 5, the longtime couple went to Dave & Busters at the Sugarloaf Mills Mall in Lawrenceville, where they met up with friends to play games at the eatery's arcade and grab dinner, Reidling told Fox News Digital. Elijiah Dewitt. Facebook When they were ready to order food, Reidling said DeWitt kissed her on the forehead and gave her his credit card, she told the outlet. She went to the bathroom first and when she came out, she said her boyfriend was nowhere in sight. When she stepped outside to look for him, she saw DeWitt lying on the pavement. "Everything's red," she told Fox News Digital. Panicked, she ran over to him. "I checked his pulse, and I got freaked out because there is nothing going on there. Some sweet lady came around the corner and said, 'Baby, he just got shot. Calm down. We called 911. They're already on their way.'" Police arrived shortly after 8:15 p.m. and found DeWitt "deceased on the ground with several gunshot wounds," the Gwinnett Police Department said in a statement. "His life just came completely to a screeching halt in seconds," his mother Dawn Dewitt told Fox 5 Atlanta. On Friday, the Gwinnett Police Department announced that two suspects — Kemare Bryan, 18, of Lawrenceville, and Chandler Richardson, 19, of Lawrenceville — were located in South Carolina and were arrested and charged in connection with DeWitt's death. Chandler Richardson, Kemare Bryan. Gwinnett County Police (2) On Tuesday, they were brought back to Georgia where they were booked into the Gwinnett County Jail. They are both charged with with felony murder, malice murder, aggravated assault, and possession of a firearm during the commission of certain felonies in connection with the murder of Elijah Dewitt, police said in the statement. It is unclear whether they have retained attorneys who can speak on their behalf. The Gwinnett Police said in an update that "detectives have reason to believe that this was not a random encounter and that some of the parties involved in the incident were known to each other." Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up forPEOPLE's free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases. Authorities had said an altercation had taken place between Dewitt, Richardson and Bryan in the parking lot, the Gwinnett Post Daily reports. Elijah Would Forgive Them DeWitt's father, Craig DeWitt, said he has forgiven his son's killers. "Forgiveness is for the forgiver," he told Fox 5. "We don't want the hate in this household." Reidling also said she forgives the suspects: "Elijah would forgive them," she told Fox News Digital. "There's something in my heart telling me to. I haven't got any hatred towards them. Anger? Yes." The teen's mother called her son a kind soul, saying, "I want him to be remembered as a fierce competitor with a very large heart," Fox 5 Atlanta reports. The suspects are scheduled to appear in court just hours before DeWitt's funeral Wednesday. DeWitt's aunt, Lauren DeWitt, thanked well-wishers on Facebook and noted that a GoFundMe has been set up to help the family. "Even though we can't respond to everyone just yet, we feel the love and it's helping. It hits harder each day as we miss him more and more."