The pair bond with a few fans in the make-up aisle in Target

By Danielle Anderson
November 02, 2015 04:30 PM
Jason Davis/Getty Images

Country’s hottest group Little Big Town opens up about their life on the road and how they still get goosebumps making music together. Subscribe now for exclusive family photos and an inside look into what makes them work, only in PEOPLE!

The members of Little Big Town are used to meeting fans while they’re out and about running errands in town. It comes with the territory of being country’s hottest group.

But a recent fan encounter in the make-up section of a Bemidji, Minnesota Target store left Kimberly Schlapman and Karen Fairchild chuckling.

“We met some girls the other day that were buying eyelashes to come to our show, while we were buying eyelashes for our show!” Fairchild tells PEOPLE.

The LBT singers say it all just proves how much they have in common with their fans.

“We were like, ‘Oh gosh, we’ve got to get some eyelashes,’ so we were in the eyelash aisle and they were buying eyelashes, so we all stood there and talked about eyelashes!”

Little Big Town

For more from Little Big Town, check out the PEOPLE Country insert in the latest issue of PEOPLE, on newsstands now.