Plus: More star sightings!

By People Staff
December 01, 2011 05:55 AM
Sara Jaye Weiss/Startraks; WireImage

File under: new friends? Zachary Quinto and Twilight‘s Peter Facinelli were spotted hanging out together for much of the evening at the Andaz Wall Street, where the actors attended the afterparty for the Gotham Independent Film Awards. Guests – including How I Met Your Mother‘s Josh Radnor – snacked on small bites from Wall & Water, the restaurant inside the hotel, and drank Russian Standard cocktails. Radnor was also spotted chatting up Felicity Jones, who earlier won the breakthrough actor award for her role in Like Crazy. – Kristin Boehm

NEXT: Jamie-Lynn Sigler Gets Into a Light Saber Fight!