Broadway's original Elphaba and Galinda from Wicked sing their tear-jerker in a new video: See it here first!
Credit: Richard Corkery/NY Daily News Archive via Getty

Well, this performance needs no help from Galinda to be popular.

Broadway’s original Elphaba and Galinda (or Glinda, if you’re Dr. Dillamond) from Wicked – a.k.a. Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth, respectively – have reunited to perform their iconic duet from their Tony-nominated musical for the first time in 12 years.

A video of their new performance of “For Good” was first shown at Second Stage Theatre’s gala honoring Wicked producer David Stone on Monday, but PEOPLE can now be the first to debut the reunion to the public.

The number marks the first time Menzel, 44, and Chenoweth, 47, have performed together since they hung up their broom and wand after the 2004 Tony Awards.

Related Video: The Real Kristin Chenoweth, Revealed!

The performance was produced as part of Wicked‘s YouTube channel‘s series Out of Oz: Wicked Studio Sessions, which features Wicked alumni and current performers singing reimagined versions of songs from the hit musical.