Celebrity Who Should Play Spider-Man's Love Interest? Which actress would best fill Mary Jane's shoes in the next film? By People Staff Published on September 30, 2010 11:20 AM Share Tweet Pin Email Photo: Xposure; Landov; Startraks; LFI The upcoming Spider-Man reboot already has its star: The Social Network‘s Andrew Garfield. Now the blogosphere is buzzing about who will capture the plum role of the web-slinger’s red-headed true love, Mary Jane Watson (played by Kirsten Dunst in the previous Spider-Man films). With plenty of casting suggestions flying, a few of our favorites are listed below.