Tim McGraw and Faith Hill Bring Daughters to the 'Time' 100 Gala – and Make a New Reality Star Friend

The country superstar is fêted at the Time 100 Gala alongside his family

Photo: Kevin Mazur/Getty

The McGraw girls are all grown up – and oh so pretty!

When country superstar Tim McGraw attended the TIME 100 gala on Tuesday night in New York City, where he was honored by the magazine as one of the most influential people in the world, he had four very special ladies by his side to help him celebrate: wife Faith Hill and daughters Gracie, 17 (whom he announced will be attending New York University in the fall), Maggie, 16, and Audrey, 13.

Yet despite being considered one of the world’s most influential people, McGraw, 47, has admitted that being a dad keeps him humble.

“You never feel like you are doing everything right as a parent,” McGraw previously told PEOPLE. “Especially when you have daughters. I dread the first broken heart!”

Though there were certainly no hearts breaking at this bash. Quite the opposite, actually. McGraw and Hill got to send a certain reality star’s heart fluttering.

After honoree Kim Kardashian West, who cheered on her cover star husband Kanye West met the country power couple, she Tweeted, “I met Faith Hill & Tim McGraw tonight!!!!! They are seriously my fave couple & have been since high school! It made my night! #IFannedOut.”

And apparently, the feeling was mutual. Hill Tweeted back, “@KimKardashian Loved meeting you. So genuine and kind.”

RELATED: Kimye, Tim McGraw and Faith Hill Rock the Time 100 Gala Red Carpet