The Clueless costars pick up where they left off in 1995
Credit: Richard Cartwright/ABC/Getty

In the 1995 cult classic Clueless, Cher Horowitz found her fairy-tale ending in the arms of Josh, her ever-endearing ex-stepbrother.

But then there was the one who got away (when he drove away from her at the liquor store, that is): Elton, played by Jeremy Sisto.

But now that Sisto, 37, and Cher actress Alicia Silverstone, 35, are reuniting as on-screen love interests for ABC’s Suburgatory, their characters are picking up right where they left off.

“Hey, have I given you enough time to cool off?” says Sisto, who plays single dad George Altman, in a new promo for the show. “Come on, get in, I’ll let you pick the music this time.”

In her guest spot as Eden, Silverstone ditches Circus Liquor for his car. Next stop: the Valley?