Celebrity Star Matchmaker Now that Katie Holmes and Chris Klein have called off their engagement, tell us whose shoulder each should cry on By People Staff Published on March 8, 2005 05:00 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Trending Videos 01 of 02 Katie Holmes, 26 B. Davila/Startraks; B. Vincent/Getty; J. Devaney/WireImage; L.Conn/ZUMA The Ohio-raised youngest of five needs a guy who keeps a low profile: She prefers quiet nights at home to the Hollywood party circuit. Who should she date?Josh Jackson: She has a soft spot for her Dawson's Creek exMarc Blucas: Her First Daughter costar is tight with family just like she isBenjamin McKenzie: The handsome O.C. star lacks pretense 02 of 02 Chris Klein, 25 M. Curtis/Startraks; L. Conn/ZUMA; F. Allende/Celebrity; L. Conn/ZUMA The midwestern high-school footballer and Texas Christian University grad stars in quirky comedies and wants some fun in his personal life. Who should he date?Jennifer Love Hewitt: She shares his small-town roots (she's from Waco, Texas)Tara Reid: The party girl is also a football fanShannon Elizabeth: His American Pie costar is back on the market