Star Matchmaker

The Ohio-raised youngest of five needs a guy who keeps a low profile: She prefers quiet nights at home to the Hollywood party circuit.

Who should she date?
Josh Jackson: She has a soft spot for her Dawson's Creek ex
Marc Blucas: Her First Daughter costar is tight with family just like she is
Benjamin McKenzie: The handsome O.C. star lacks pretense

The midwestern high-school footballer and Texas Christian University grad stars in quirky comedies and wants some fun in his personal life.

Who should he date?
Jennifer Love Hewitt: She shares his small-town roots (she's from Waco, Texas)
Tara Reid: The party girl is also a football fan
Shannon Elizabeth: His American Pie costar is back on the market