PEOPLE's 'Most Beautiful' Celebrities Posing with Their Younger Selves

On April 23, PEOPLE will unveil its 2014 list of the World’s Most Beautiful celebrities, adding a new cover star to the ranks of Beyoncé, Gwyneth Paltrow, Leonardo DiCaprio and Julia Roberts.

Each year since 1990, PEOPLE has chosen a celebrity lineup that’s gorgeous both inside and out. To prove that true beauty never ages, we used some Photoshop magic to reconnect the “Most Beautiful” stars of years past with their younger selves. See the 19 pairings below, sorted by the year – or years – they earned their title:

All photo illustrations by Linzi Silverman and Tiffany Hagler-Geard for PEOPLE.com.

1990, 1999: Michelle Pfeiffer

1991, 2000, 2005, 2010: Julia Roberts

1992: Jodie Foster

1993: Cindy Crawford

1994: Meg Ryan

1995: Courteney Cox

1996: Mel Gibson

1997: Tom Cruise

1998: Leonardo DiCaprio

2001: Catherine Zeta-Jones

2002: Nicole Kidman

2003: Halle Berry

2004: Jennifer Aniston

2006: Angelina Jolie

2007: Drew Barrymore

2008: Kate Hudson

2009: Christina Applegate

2011: Jennifer Lopez

2012: Beyoncé Knowles

2013: Gwyneth Paltrow

RELATED: Oscar Nominees Posing with Their Younger Selves

PHOTOS: Sneak Peek: 2014’s World’s Most Beautiful List