The reality star wed his longtime girlfriend in Ohio on Saturday night
Carroll and Stone were joined by more than 250 friends and family at the nuptials and reception, which included a Miami-inspired cocktail hour that featured fun pairings like mini fish tacos and Patron shots.
Later in the evening, guests danced to the Ken Arlen Orchestra before heading to the afterparty at the Ritz Carlton Cleveland’s Muse restaurant.
The wedding and reception was planned by Reva Nathan & Associates, designed by HMR Designs and shot by celebrity photographers Bob and Dawn Davis, who have shot events for celebrities including Oprah and Eva Longoria.
Carroll, an executive vice president at Douglas Elliman Real Estate, and Stone, a spokesperson and video reporter for Delray Beach Marketplace and a freelance entertainment reporter, will head to Australia and New Zealand for their honeymoon.
“We were set up through a mutual family friend at an Ohio State football party,” Stone tells PEOPLE. “Chad asked me out through Facebook, saying he had ‘work to do’ in Boca Raton, where I was living at the time. Without any real work to do up there, he then slept at his grandparents’ house for the next three days in a row so we could be together. We pretty much haven’t separated since.”