At Wednesday’s Old Navy and Lyft collaboration at The Rink in Bryant Park in New York City, the pop star, 32, discussed her blossoming relationship and her favorite parts of the holiday season — in particular, sleeping in and not needing to get up at a particular time.
“Having the morning and having a bagel, I know it’s so silly and stupid, but that is so romantic to me,” she gushes. “Not having plans, you don’t have to get up and rush. And it’s cold outside, maybe it’s snowing and we’re just sleeping in. The best.”
Finding a gift for her fiancé isn’t quite so relaxing, though.
“I don’t know the secret yet,” she muses. “I’ll tell you that. I’m still trying to figure it out. I just think that I take cues all year. I’ll just kinda try to see if I hear anything, and I’ll wait the whole year.” (On the other hand, she’s easy to shop for: “There’s no planting seeds. I’m totally out there and open. Spa gift certificate, candles, pajamas … It’s like, just please buy me this and nothing else.”)
The Glee alumna also revealed that her preferred holiday movies are The Family Stone and Love, Actually, which she always watches on either Christmas Eve or Christmas Day, and her favorite seasonal songs are Mariah Carey’s “All I Want For Christmas Is You” and Judy Garland’s “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas.”
Her Christmas list also includes sweaters and books, she says, adding, “I just love anything that’s gonna make me feel cozy … I just got off of taking one flight every day for two weeks. Sleeping in a different hotel every night and so when it comes to having the actual time to do nothing, I wanna feel good while I do.”
This holiday, also joining Michele — who wore a Fair Isle sweater and those celeb-fave Rockstar jeans, both by Old Navy, to sing carols with the New York City Gay Men’s Chorus at the Bryant Park skating rink — will her mom and dad.
“We’re just gonna be cozied up together, the four of us. Super simple cooking, Christmas movies, hanging out relaxing in pajamas,” she says.
Michele’s holiday season isn’t entirely about comfort, though. She shared that her New Year’s resolution (aside from cutting back on Bravo reruns) will be focused on wasting food less.
“I order more food than I eat and I buy more food and I wanna be more conscious and less wasteful, because I feel like a lot of times I get too much and then I send it back,” she explains. “So, I wanna just be a little bit more thoughtful about that.”
Earlier this year, the Scream Queens actress opened up about her engagement to PEOPLE and revealed how she knew Reich was the one.
“When you’re meeting someone, you have to see right off the gate how they travel and if you travel well together,” she said. “Luckily, when we first met, we realized that we do travel well together. That is a big relationship key, I think.”
Michele announced her engagement to Reich on Instagram in late April, posting a photo of herself with her left hand on her face. “Yes,” she wrote in the caption, alongside a diamond ring emoji.
“It was a super private proposal,” a friend of the actress told PEOPLE just days after the big moment. “Their relationship has been very private, but they’re so happy. It was so romantic and she’s just so excited and feels so lucky. He’s a really nice guy. Lea is extremely happy.”
Reich gave Michele a four-carat diamond ring personally custom designed for her with Leor Yerushalmi and The Jewelers of Las Vegas.