Kim and Kourtney Kardashian share their surprising wishlist for Feb. 14

Credit: Seth Browarnik/Startraks

She may idolize Elizabeth Taylor – and her famous bling – but for Kim Kardashian, Feb. 14 is about much simpler sentiments.

For Valentine’s Day, “I like a long card,” the reality star, 30, told PEOPLE at a QVC fashion week event in NYC Friday. “Write me your feelings – it s all about the feelings and the card.” (Did you get that, Kris Humphries?)

Her sister, on the other hand, is hoping for something a bit more sparkly.

“For me, diamonds will do the trick,” says Kourtney, 31, with a grin.

The sisters, who live in Los Angeles and shoot their spin-off series in New York, are on the move again for Valentine s Day.

“We will both be in Vegas,” says Kourtney.

Hoping, no doubt, to be lucky in love.