Holly Madison's Wedding: Inside Her Disneyland Ceremony

With the entire park shut down, guests took the Pirates of the Caribbean ride after the ceremony

Walt Disney would have been proud.

Holly’s Madison’s dreams became a reality on Tuesday night with an over-the-top wedding that could only happen at the Happiest Place on Earth.

“It was really spectacular,” a wedding guest tells PEOPLE. “They spared no expense.”

Madison and beau Pasquale Rotella tied the knot at Disneyland’s New Orleans Square (the couple’s 6-month-old daughter, Rainbow Aurora, was the guest of honor) after an evening cocktail party.

Then the wedding party and its guests headed to the rides.

After a turn on the Pirates of the Caribbean, a train carried guests to the reception where they were treated to a private showing of Fantasmic!, the evening show that features pyrotechnics, live actors on the water surrounding Tom Sawyer Island.

With the park closed, guests noshed from a buffet of food and candy, and had the decision of eating from not one, but two cakes – one for her, and one for him.

Rotella produces large-scale electronic music festivals, so not just any wedding deejay would do. The couple danced to the sounds of Grammy-nominated deejay Kaskade while fireworks exploded overhead.

PHOTOS: Summer’s Hottest Weddings

It was, according to the source, “truly a fairly tale.”

The wedding comes three months after the couple was engaged during the Electric Daisy Carnival while, no surprise here, aboard a Ferris wheel with an 18-carat yellow diamond ring. They had been dating since late 2011.