Fashion Faceoff

At a recent benefit in New York City, Linda Evangelista (right) shimmered in a 1920s-style Lanvin frock similar to the one Nicole Kidman wore in L.A. earlier this year. Who looks fancier as a flapper – the Oscar winner or the catwalker?

Actress Elise Neal (right) donned the same embroidered blouse in Los Angeles recently that Eve wore at a premiere in Hollywood a month earlier. Who's prettier in pink – the rapper or the Hustle & Flow star?

At a New York City gala recently, Kelly Ripa (right) glowed in the same red-sashed Valentino gown Salma Hayek showed off in Cannes this summer. Who looks more stellar – the Frida hottie or the talk-show host?

Garcelle Beauvais-Nilon (left) wore the same chocolate-colored dress in Los Angeles recently that Cynthia Nixon donned at an L.A. fund-raiser days earlier. Who's more becoming in brown – the Sex and the City siren or the Barbershop 2 babe?

With a cashmere sweater, Paris Hilton (right, in Beverly Hills) gives a fall update to the blooming Moschino frock that Jessica Simpson donned this summer in New York City. Who looks rosier – the singer or the heiress?

In New York City recently, Jennifer Jason Leigh (right) wore a multi-colored version of the Prada dress that Faith Hill wore to an awards show just days before. Who has more panache – the Grammy winner or the indie actress?

Lee Ann Womack (right) was spotted at a New York City event in the same gray Roland Mouret dress that Christine Taylor donned at a charity gala weeks earlier. Who's more of a hit – the country singer or the Dodgeball star?

At the American Music Awards, Paula Abdul (right) showcased her curves in a full-length version of the sexy Dolce amp Gabbana frock that Serena Williams wore in Atlantic City a month earlier. Who's more sultry – the tennis champ or the American Idol judge?

In West Hollywood recently, Paris Hilton (right) hopped to it in a gray rabbit-print thermal by Primp; earlier, Rachel Bilson donned it in pink. Who's better in bunny – the O.C. actress or the hotel heiress?

In New York City, Underworld: Evolution star Kate Beckinsale (right) paired a belted black trench with knee-high boots – the same look Angelina Jolie sported at the Tokyo Mr. & Mrs. Smith. premiere.

Sienna Miller and Sadie Frost share more than their taste in men: In London recently, Frost (right) wore a military-style coat similar to Miller's beloved Balenciaga jacket. Who looks more commanding – Jude Law's off-and-on sweetie or his onetime spouse?

In New York City, Nicollette Sheridan (right) warmed up in the same Juicy Couture trench that Natalie Portman sported there a few weeks earlier. Who looks better in bouclé – the queen of Naboo or the diva of Wisteria Lane?

At a party for Calvin Klein in New York City, Molly Sims (right) wore the designer's shimmering, shoulder-baring dress – the same one Lindsay Lohan flaunted in L.A. Who's cooler in Calvin – the Long Island native or the Las Vegas actress?

Garcelle Beauvais-Nilon (right) shimmered in Marc Bouwer in Beverly Hills recently; Christina Milian glittered in the same dress at a New York City party. Who sparkles more in sequins – the "Dip It Low" singer or the former NYPD Blue D.A.?

At a party in New York City, Amanda Peet (right) wore an Isaac Mizrahi dress similar to the one Selma Blair donned at another Big Apple event. Who's more see-worthy in see-through – the dark-haired cutie or the blue-eyed beauty?