People.com Celebrity Fashion Faceoff By People Staff Published on February 16, 2006 02:00 PM Share Tweet Pin Email 01 of 09 BEYONCé VS. LINDSAY Ash Knotek/Snappers/Zuma; Sara Jaye/Abaca Beyoncé (left) and Lindsay Lohan wore the same cropped rabbit-fur vest to recent events. Who looks better – the "Naughty Girl" or the Mean Girl? 02 of 09 JESSICA VS. EVA John Smith/startraksphoto; Tom Marvin In New York City recently, Jessica Simpson (left) sported her Daisy Duke character's trademark shorts and cowboy boots. The next day, Eva Longoria wore a similar getup in L.A. Who looks better – the Hazzard hottie or the Desperate diva? 03 of 09 HILARY VS. LISA MARIE Sthanlee B. Mirador/Shooting Star; Charley Gallay/LEP/Splash Hilary Swank (left) and Lisa Marie Presley wore the same sundress from Malibu's Planet Blue boutique to recent rockin' events. Who looks cooler – the Million Dollar Baby or Elvis's baby? 04 of 09 JENNIFER VS. NICOLE Bauer-Griffin;Mark VonHolden/DMI Jennifer Aniston (left) and Nicole Richie wore the same tie-dyed Prada dress to recent events. Who looks better – the former Friend or Paris Hilton's onetime BFF? 05 of 09 JESSICA VS. BEYONCE MB PICTURES/REX;ANDREA RENAULT/GLOBE Jessica Simpson (left) sported a sky-blue Jean Paul Gaultier dress in Beverly Hills recently, while Beyonce wore a different version in New York City. Which singer looks more heavenly? 06 of 09 JENNIFER VS. HELENA Charles Sykes/Rex; Tim Whitby/WireImage In London recently, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory's Helena Bonham Carter (right) wore a fringed Alberta Ferretti frock similar to the one Jennifer Lopez donned in New York City in May. Who looks better – J.Lo or H.Bo? 07 of 09 MARCIA VS. SOFIA Gregorio binuya/everett collection; Brian Prahl/Splash News Desperate Housewives star Marcia Cross (left) and Four Brothers actress Sofia Vergara wore the same gold Dolce amp Gabbana dress during recent New York City outings. Who looks better – the small-screen stunner or the striking big-screen ingenue? 08 of 09 MISCHA VS. KIRSTEN RAMEY; Fernando Allende/NY Post/Splash Mischa Barton (left) wore a flowing Chloe frock to a Beverly Hills dinner, while Kirsten Dunst wore the same dress to MTV's Video Music Awards, sans leggings. Which look is best: O.C. casual or red-carpet rock star? 09 of 09 LINDSAY VS. GERI Jon Kopaloff/Filmmagic; Malibu Media Lindsay Lohan (left) and Geri Halliwell wore slinky black Gucci dresses to recent red-carpet events. Who looks better – the onetime ginger-haired actress or the former Ginger Spice?