Celebrity Fashion Faceoff By People Staff Published on November 10, 2005 11:40 AM Share Tweet Pin Email 01 of 06 PARIS VS. PAULA VS. DEBRA WENN/Landov; Gregg DeGuire/WireImage. Paris Hilton (left), Paula Abdul and Debra Messing all wore Dolce amp Gabbana dresses to recent red-carpet events. Who looks most stylish – the House of Wax star, the American Idol judge or the Will amp Grace actress? 02 of 06 MARIAH VS. MELANIA VALERIE GOODLOE/GLOBE; nicolas khayat/abaca Mariah Carey (left) and Melania Trump donned the same satin-and-tulle Alexander McQueen ball gown at recent red-carpet events. Who looks better – the pop diva or The Donald's better half? 03 of 06 LINDSAY VS. NICOLE Jonathan Friolo / IHP / Splash; Fame Friends Lindsay Lohan (left) and Nicole Richie both wore a white shift, a black camisole and jeans and carried an oversized blue tote recently. Who looks better – the Drama Queen or the Simple Life star? 04 of 06 JESSICA VS. NICOLLETTE Gilbert Flores/Celebrity; ACE Jessica Simpson (left) and Nicollette Sheridan wore the same curve-hugging Valentino dress for a night out. Who looks better – the Newlywed or the Housewife? 05 of 06 MISCHA VS. PARIS Fernando Allende/Celebrity Photo; Jeff Vespa/Wireimage Mischa Barton (left) and Paris Hilton both wore the same daring blue satin Chloe dress to recent red carpet events. Who looks better, the O.C. star or the House of Wax scream queen? 06 of 06 JESSICA VS. AMBER INF; Luis Martinez / AFF-USA Jessica Alba (left) and Hitch actress Amber Valletta both wore a strapless fuchsia Marc Jacobs dress to recent red-carpet events. Who looks better – the Sin City star or the former model?