Celebrity hot-spot Craig’s was swarming with more A-listers than usual when many of its VIP regulars came out to celebrate founder Craig Susser’s 50th birthday at the Los Angeles restaurant on Saturday night.
Cindy Crawford, Sarah Silverman, David Spade, Elton John, Jackie Collins, Emmy Rossum, Jeff Ross, Molly Sims, Ryan Phillippe, Don Rickles and David Foster were all in attendance at the private event, which included roasts, toasts and – of course – lots of delicious food.
Guests feasted on honey-truffle chicken, lamb chops, oysters, crab legs, shrimp cocktail, chili, pigs-in-a-blanket, sliders, pizza and caviar over eggs, while sipping on Casamigos tequila drinks.
For those looking to satisfy their sweet tooth there were old-fashioned cigarette girls who were passing out Craig’s favorite candy.
Among the toasters were Ross, Phillippe and Rickles.
“Jeff Ross joked that Craig’s is the Olive Garden for celebrities,” a guest tells PEOPLE. “Don Rickles giving a funny, sentimental toast was the big hit. The was room full of amazing, warm, caring people – celebrities and non-celebrities – who have made Craig’s their home and who wanted to celebrate his 50th.”