Ashlee: The New Jessica?

They could be twins! Since her nose job, Ashlee has been looking a lot like big sis Jessica – in more ways than one. Who owns the look? You decide

THEIR HAIR STYLES

Mark Mainz/Getty; Jae C. Hong/AP

"We have a new Ashlee," the younger Simpson (left) told Entertainment Tonight of her long blonde look, now being tended to by Ken Paves – the stylist pal who gave Jessica (right) her signature locks.

THEIR MIC MOVES

Aaron Settipane / WENN; Phillippe Noisette/ Star File

Jessica will always have her Daisy Dukes (right), but Ashlee takes her Dickies even lower onstage while on tour in Los Angeles.

THEIR POSES

Michael Buckner/Getty;Gilbert Flores/Celebrity Photo

Ashlee (left) walks the press line like a pro in Las Vegas, with hand to hip, just like Jessica.

THEIR ACCESSORIES

X17; ZXING/SNAP-PIX

Jessica (right) was first to get a handle on Louis Vuitton handbags – even taking hers camping. Now Ashlee is carrying the luxury logo regularly (left, in Beverly Hills), and has an LV travel set too.

THEIR PETS

Chris Gordon/Getty; Rob Grabowski/Retna

Ashlee (left) shares the spotlight onstage with her new Yorkie pup Hula, while Jessica's been known to show off Maltipoo Daisy during cuddly duets.

THEIR GUYS

Chris Polk/FilmMagic;Frank Micelotta/Getty

Before, it was all about Nick and Jessica (right, in 2005). Now, Ashlee is the one coordinating with a steady red-carpet date: bandmate Braxton Olita. But who looked best together?

Ashlee's Other LookalikesASHLEE vs. FAITH

Mark Mainz/Getty ; Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic

Looking sweet in lace, Ashlee creates a double take with another singer, Faith Hill.

ASHLEE VS. KATE

x17; Flynet

Who's who? Behind those shades it's Ashlee (left) and Kate Hudson.

ASHLEE VS. ASHLEY

X17 (2)

A big bag and oversized sunglasses may be an Olsen staple (right), but a Simpson has a lot to carry too (left)!

For more Ashlee lookalikes, check out this week's issue of PEOPLE, on newsstands now.