In The Boy Who Knew Too Much, Christian Haupt's mother describes her family's belief that the boy was Lou Gehrig in a past life

By Diane Herbst
March 21, 2017 10:27 AM
Products in this story are independently selected and featured editorially. If you make a purchase using these links we may earn commission.

Cathy Byrd’s 2-year-old son, Christian Haupt, was a baseball prodigy who spent countless hours pitching and hitting balls, and insisted on wearing a baseball uniform every day. In 2011 his outstanding abilities even landed the boy a small part in the Adam Sandler movie That’s My Boy.

But in her new memoir, The Boy Who Knew Too Much, Byrd shares an even more improbable story that even she had trouble believing at first: She claims that Christian was the reincarnation of baseball legend Lou Gehrig, who played for the Yankees nearly a century ago.

Byrd had not believed in reincarnation. But she says she began to explore it based on the statements Christian makes about Gehrig’s life that she says the young child could not have otherwise known.

She then confirms his statements through Google searches, radio and TV shows, books and searches of Gehrig archives.

When Byrd, a California realtor, told two close friends about Christian’s past life stories he’d share, her friends rejected the notion and one told her, “You really need to get over this, Cathy.”

Byrd herself was highly skeptical at first about Christian’s revelations. She writes they began when he blurted out: “Mommy, I used to be a tall baseball player.”


When she tells him he will be a tall baseball player someday, he replies: “No! I was a tall baseball player—tall like Daddy!”

Still too young to read, and not exposed to any baseball lore from his non-baseball-fan family, Byrd writes that Christian shared baseball history he could not possibly have known, such as players traveling by train to hotels.

RELATED VIDEO: Twitter Goes Crazy After Man Saves a Boy From Being Hit in face by Baseball Bat

When Christian sees a photo of Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig, Byrd says that her son declared: “they didn’t talk to each other.”

Byrd discovers it was true that the once-tight pals had a falling out and no longer spoke. “And there was no reasonable explanation as to how he would know such a thing,” she writes. “When I asked him how he knew, he replied, ‘I just know.’ ”

Christian Haupt

“I found myself straddling the great divide between logic and intuition,” writes Byrd, a practicing Catholic. “The concept of reincarnation was diametrically opposed to my rational thoughts and my religious beliefs, yet my heart was telling me not to ignore what Christian was so desperately trying to tell me.”

Byrd also seeks help along the way from a psychologist, and from a professor at the University of Virginia, Jim B. Tucker, M.D., author of Return to Life: Extraordinary Cases of Children Who Remember Past Lives.

It was during a meeting with Tucker that Christian delivers the startling news that he chose Byrd to be his mother when she was born.

She writes that Christian said: “I picked her to be my mom, and then she got old.”

When Tucker asks Christian when he picked Byrd, she writes that Christian said, without hesitation, “In the sky.”

Tucker then stuns Byrd by telling her that many children in the cases he’s studied recall choosing their parents.

At another point, Christian points to a photo of Lou Gehrig’s mother, Christina Gehrig, and says, “Mommy, you were her.”

Byrd launches her own private journey of self-discovery by meeting with a past-life regression therapist. During the sessions, she says she has recollections as Christina Gehrig, which Byrd then seeks to verify.

In one past-life regression session, Byrd describes jewelry Lou Gehrig had given her that she gave away to a family.

The author then researches who this family may have been, tracks them down, and confirms that Christina Gehrig had indeed given the family women’s jewelry from Japan and a watch she spoke of during the hypnotic regression.

FROM COINAGE: These athletes are raking in the most endorsement money

She writes: “Hearing that the jewelry I’d described while under hypnosis was actually in the possession of the Steigler family proved to me once and for all that the information coming through during my past-life regressions was anchored in reality.”

The Boy Who Knew Too Much is on sale Tuesday and, in its next life, will hit the big screen.