That’s going to be one funny kid!
Arriving at 4:29 p.m., the new addition was born in Los Angeles.
Want all the latest pregnancy and birth announcements, plus celebrity mom blogs? Click here to get those and more in the PEOPLE Babies newsletter.
RELATED VIDEO: Jordan Peele reveals elopement with Chelsea Peretti on Seth Meyers
“I am married to actress Chelsea Peretti,” Peele said during a segment in which he and Key shared trivia about each other to help people tell them apart.
“I am not married to actress Chelsea Peretti, we are just dating,” Key joked, earning quite the look from his comedy partner.
Speaking to PEOPLE in March, Peele admitted that “this child will be comedy gold” and that their baby announcement was pretty much unavoidable.
“You want to get into the zone where you feel like, ‘Okay, now this is happening,’ and really it got to the point where hiding it really wasn’t an option,” he explained of Peretti’s bump, adding that the couple have “gotten such a warm reaction” to their news.
“We’re so excited, and it’s surreal and cool,” the star added. “My wife is just a very beautiful and spectacular pregnant person.”
Of his hush-hush nuptials, Peele shared that, in his mind, there were no downsides. “Oh my God, what aren’t the pros of eloping?” he said. “I’m not a very crowd-oriented person. I feel like I’m great one-on-one, I’m okay with two people, with three I’m a little bit worse.”
FROM PEN: The Mummy Star Annabelle Wallis On How She Almost Puked on Tom Cruise
Since the couple’s baby news broke, Peretti has been keeping her social-media followers updated on the progress of her growing bump — alongside a dose of hilarity, of course.
“Thinking about a variety of snacks after a lengthy nap. Here I am in a sexy red dress!!!!!!!!!!” she captioned a mirror-selfie post in late April, where she’s outfitted in a flowy garment.
“VROOM VROOOOOOMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM BEEPBEEPBEEEEEPBEEEEEEEPBEEPBEEPP whats a good rocking chair,” she added.
E! was first to report the happy news.