After a 2011 comeback that netted an Oscar and a slew of new fans, our felt pals return to face Ricky Gervais, as a dim criminal, and his boss, a dead ringer for a certain frog. “We’re paying homage to classic capers,” says producer David Hoberman. (Tina Fey and Ty Burell also star.) As for Piggy and Kermie, Hoberman hints they may finally get back together. Then again, “we might fake you out.” You rascals!