June 11, 2014 12:00 PM

Hunter Hayes

AGE 22 • SINGLE

“Any time someone makes a comment on my eyes, I feel like they’re staring deep into my soul,” says Hayes. “When you focus on someone’s eyes like that, you can see them travel through their thought process and get a feel for the rhythm of their heart. A lot can be communicated with just the look in your eye.” In fact, letting his eyes do a bit of the talking can be helpful, says Hayes. “I’m one to just introduce myself and say, ‘Just so you know, I’m awkward and I have no idea what I’m saying right now, and I will not be offended if you tell me you’re not remotely interested.’ That’s actually been my pickup line.”

David Nail

AGE 35 • MARRIED

Kennett High School yearbook committee of 1997, you got it wrong! “I never got ‘prettiest eyes’ in high school for some reason,” says Nail, who hails from Kennett, Mo. “But as I’ve gotten older more people are commenting on them. Maybe they’re just getting better with age!” Though there’s one person who has appreciated his peepers all along. “My wife does comment on my eyes. She tells me they are a mixture of blue, hazel and green,” says Nail. “But hopefully she thinks I’m the whole package.”

Chris Young

AGE 28 • SINGLE

When you’re this sexy, you just can’t be boxed into a category. “My driver’s license says my eyes are brown,” says Young, “but they’re actually multicolored. They’re brown around the outside, then toward the center there’s some blue and a little bit of green in there. My eyes are confused I guess.” Luckily those confused eyes can still send clear signals. “I make a living singing and talking all the time, so when I’m with someone and we’re just exchanging glances, I think that’s sexy as hell!”

You May Like

EDIT POST