He may not have found love in Paradise, but it looks like Wells Adams is officially off the market.
The Bachelorette and Bachelor in Paradise alum recently sparked romance rumors with Modern Family actress Sarah Hyland after they celebrated Halloween together — and now, Hyland seems to have confirmed that the two are an item.
“He puts up with me,” she captioned a photo of herself sticking her tongue out, leaning into Adams.
Adams shared his own adorable photo of the couple staring lovingly into each other’s eyes in front of a twinkly backyard.
“Back lit AF,” he quipped.
RELATED VIDEO: Sarah Hyland Reveals Her Modern Family Character Is Bisexual
For Halloween, Adams, 33, and Hyland, 26, dressed up as characters from Stranger Things together, sharing plenty of photos on social media.
“#strangerthings have happened,” she captioned a shot of Adams clutching a box of Eggo waffles as Eleven while she grinned in costume as Dustin Henderson.
“11 hangin’ out with a 10,” Adams captioned his own shot.
At the time, a source told PEOPLE the two have “been friends for a while and now they’ve been hanging out and spending more time together.”
“They’re flirty,” the source added.
Adams took over Bachelor in Paradise bartending duties from the beloved Jorge this summer. During his time on BiP, sparks flew between the radio DJ and contestant Danielle Maltby — both Nashville residents and longtime friend — but Maltby left Mexico early in pursuit of a career opportunity in Africa.
“The problem with being single isn’t the fact that you’re alone,” she wrote Oct. 11. “It’s that you can’t puppy dog eye a guy into getting you Starbucks in bed.”
When a fan pointed out that dating apps are always an option, the actress admitted she wasn’t a fan.
“Yuck gross. To each their own but dating apps aren’t for me,” she said. “I like the natural progression of a person slowly learning im [sic] crazy.”