“They aren’t dating anymore but they both have mutual respect for one another and remain friends,” a source tells PEOPLE.
In January, Hyland shared a steamy make-out post of the couple to Instagram. “What really happens at the #goldenglobes with @domsherwood,” she captioned a video of her and Sherwood kissing in an elevator.
“Happy 2 year to my #1 @domsherwood,” Hyland captioned another photo posted to Instagram in February of the pair on a hiking trail together in celebration of their two-year anniversary. “(I wrote a sappy thing for your birthday so… yeah).”
Hyland previously dated actor Matt Prokop for five years. Their relationship ended in 2014 when Hyland obtained a temporary restraining order against him amid allegations that he physically assaulted her and threatened her life.