In a sneak peek at Monday’s episode of the musical rom-com exclusive to PEOPLE, titular hopeless romantic Rebecca (Rachel Bloom) fantasizes about her former flame Josh (Vincent Rodriguez III) cloned into four perfectly choreographed pop stars … who also happen to be “a team of licensed professional mental health professionals.”
Each Josh is different yet equally swoon-worthy in an all-white outfit – Pucca shells! A bucket cap! An artfully unbuttoned business shirt! – reminiscent of ‘NSYNC at its 2000s best.
“Baby, you can kiss all your childhood trauama goodbye,” they croon. “All your psychological problems / Girl, we’re gonna solve ’em.”
Watch the tongue-in-cheek performance above, and catch Crazy Ex-Girlfriend on Monday at 8 p.m. ET on the CW.