“I’ve been working out, trying to keep up,” Sullivan said. “My trainer’s been having me work my arms so hard last week, I couldn’t straighten my arms for three days. Biceps so tight.”
Fallon was in support. “Listen to this, PEOPLE magazine,” he said, telling Sullivan, “I’ll see you in PEOPLE magazine!”
“Now don’t get me wrong, those are three sexy men,” he said, assuring there was no feud. “And on top of that, incredible actors. And on top of that, incredible guys.”
RELATED: Sterling K. Brown Gives ‘This Is Us’ Costar Major Props for His Steamy ‘Booty Shot’
The emotional episode had viewers choking back tears, but Sullivan was choking back something else while filming.
“At Kate and Toby’s wedding, I had food poisoning,” he explained. “There was sweating and a lot of [deep] breathing,”
The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon airs weeknights (11:30 p.m.) on NBC.