When Kim Kardashian debuted her 20.5-carat engagement ring last year, no one blinked an eye. Jennifer Lopez‘s reported 8-carat ring from Marc Anthony? No biggie. Beyoncé‘s 18-carat bauble? No judgment!
But for some reason, Jennifer Aniston‘s extra-large diamond — which she debuted on Saturday while visiting with fiancé Justin Theroux in New Mexico — is causing quite a stir, thanks to its eye-catching size and unique shape.
Perhaps it’s because the actress is known for her minimalist aesthetic that many people expected a simpler sparkler, but hey, in Hollywood, it’s big star, big diamond, right?
Tell us: Do you like Aniston’s ring? Vote in our poll below!