Though we all loved the looks in our Best Dressed Oscar’s 2007 Gallery, there are quite a few red carpet get-ups from Sunday night that we’re on the fence about. One person’s “gorgeous” is another’s “outrageous.” Take for example, Kirsten Dunst, who turned up to present an award with her Spider-Man co-star Tobey Macguire. Quite a few style critics thought there was just too much happening on this beaded Chanel gown, while others applauded her for doing something different from everyone else. Complicating matters even more: A whole new bevy of ladies in gowns turned out for the post-show parties, including Oprah and Ellen Pompeo. PEOPLE magazine needs your help! Click over to our Love It or Hate It? photo poll and vote now on these Oscar night looks. You’ll see the results in the next issue of PEOPLE, on sale later this week!