1 of 45
BRITNEY VS. ASHLEY
paired her Brian Lichtenberg mini with stacked black pumps and went ladylike with nude heels and a chain-strap bag. But really, who’s looking at their accessories?
2 of 45
GWEN VS. RAVEN
Both and Raven topped black décolletage-baring ensembles and chunky boots with the same funky mall store find: a yellow blazer from Zara.
3 of 45
ANNE VS. PARIS
If it weren’t for Paris’s major statement necklace, we’d swear we were seeing double: two tall blondes in pumps making a dramatic entrance in their Chagoury Couture high-slit gowns.
4 of 45
KRISTEN VS. JADA
The former SNL star wears a Valentino rosette-adorned jumpsuit with red pumps in N.Y.C., and Jada follows in her fashion-forward footsteps, turning it into a romper and adding black sandals.
5 of 45
HILLARY VS. JANE
A stunning Pamella Roland one-shoulder gown gets two different treatments: the country star rocks it in pink with an updo and the actress selects red, pairing the dress with tumbling curls.
6 of 45
GARCELLE VS. CHRISTINA
Hello, high-low! The two stars tried the hot-right-now trend with a printed blue-and-white Woodleigh maxi, but the actress kept hers beachy with wedges and shades, while the singer dressed up hers in silver pumps and jewels.
7 of 45
KATE VS. TYRA
feels white is right, adding matching shoes and earrings to her structured Marchesa gown at the 2010 Golden Globes, while goes for maximum drama in the raspberry version and mega curls in N.Y.C.
8 of 45
EMMY VS. JESSICA
Emmy’s Katharine Kidd dress is daytime-appropriate when styled with a white jacket and purple pumps in L.A.; Jessica makes the look right for a night out in N.Y.C. thanks to bare shoulders, loose curls, smoky eyes and patent pumps.
9 of 45
RIHANNA VS. LIV
Who knew a floral Givenchy top could be so versatile? dresses hers down with ripped jeans and heavy boots in N.Y.C., and Liv keeps it ladylike in a swingy blazer, fitted skirt and heels in Paris.
10 of 45
KATHLEEN VS. ELIZA
Stylish minds think alike! The Beverly Hills, 90210 actress (seen in L.A.) and the Happy Endings star (in Hollywood) both accessorize their sexy Cengiz Abazoglu minis with sleek dos, pedi-baring T-strap heels and minimal jewelry.
11 of 45
GINNIFER VS. KELLY
Both the actress and the talk show host are thinking pink with their Roksanda Ilincic dresses, but Ginnifer teams it with black accessories in L.A. and Kelly plays up the fierce shade with magenta-and-red pumps in N.Y.C.
12 of 45
GWYNETH VS. KIM
The flashes her seriously toned midriff in a beaded Emilio Pucci gown at the Emmys, while shows off her famous curves in the same two-piece design at Cannes.
13 of 45
EVA VS. HEIDI
How to make a patch-pocket Isabel Marant jumpsuit, like , even funkier? demonstrates, layering on a leather topper, a patterned scarf and two-tone sandals.
14 of 45
GARCELLE VS. MEGAN
Garcelle (our newest celebrity blogger) plays down the ultra-ladylike vibe of her $158 Maggy London dress with sandals and bold jewels, while Megan plays it straight with pumps and jewels.
15 of 45
EMMA VS. KRISTIN
Think floral denim isn’t for you? Check out how cute both of these blondes look in their Joe’s jeans. Emma adds a white tee and oversize sweater for a casual look and expectant picks tailored black separates and heels.
16 of 45
ELIZABETH VS. JENNIFER
In their Ella Moss “Castaway” dresses, the two moms do summer chic in two very different ways: Elizabeth in a casual hat, in glam shades and studded sandals. Want to get in on the Fashion Faceoff? Snag the striped dress for yourself!
17 of 45
MINKA VS. EMMA
The two stars are so hot (probably literally), rocking the warm-weather leather trend in the form of a J Brand tee, which Minka pairs with floral jeans and adds to white denim.
18 of 45
ASHLEY VS. LAURA
Go sheer, short and sexy like these two actresses in their For Love & Lemons “Lulu” dress (only $98, and still available in black!) Follow in footsteps (with peep-toes) or style it as the Ted actress does (with a cobalt clutch).
19 of 45
CHRISSY VS. BETHENNY
One mint blazer, two times of day: The Sports Illustrated model’s A.L.C. topper is perfect for the afternoon when worn with an oversize tote, a long chain necklace and wedge heels, while the makes it night-ready with a silky top, cap-toe pumps and earrings.
20 of 45
EVA VS. EMMA
Looking like a million bucks – but spending only $40! – the two stylish stars stroll L.A. in two very different takes on the same button-up Express shirt.
21 of 45
ZOOEY VS. OLIVIA
A simple summer dress doesn’t have to equal a boring summer dress. Case in point: this Rachel Zoe Collection number, which Zooey spices up with a tweed jacket and belt and Olivia accessorizes with girlie nude sandals and hoops.
22 of 45
ASHLEE VS. CATHERINE
We’re more than a little surprised to see the punky pop princess and the sophisticated movie star in the same Alice + Olivia sparkly black dress, and even more surprised that they style it similarly.
23 of 45
AMY VS. CHRISTIE
Who knew this off-the-shoulder Roland Mouret color-block sheath was such a universally flattering (and appealing) piece? Though both stars opt for bombshell waves, the actress keeps things simple with nude heels and the supermodel adds bright orange stilettos (plus, she shortened the hem).
24 of 45
AMY VS. JESSICA
Think you can’t pull off high-waisted flares? You can if you look to Amy and for styling advice. They both wisely wear their Habitual jeans with heightening shoes and tucked in tops.
25 of 45
ZOOEY VS. KIM
Wondering what kind of dress could possibly appeal to both the cutesy actress and the sexy ? Wonder no longer: it’s this Carven ensemble with a cleavage-revealing, cut-out top and a flouncy skirt.
26 of 45
KATIE VS. CHARLIZE
continues her chambray shirt addiction in Current/Elliott’s “Perfect Shirt” (worn with a bikini and bright shorts), while leaves hers unbuttoned over jeans.
27 of 45
BRANDY VS. KELLIE
Two sultry singers, two different ways of accessorizing the same Hervé Léger fringed mini. The R&B star opts for giant earrings and the puts on an armful of rose gold bangles.
28 of 45
KHLOé VS. RACHEL
More stars in one of Hollywood’s hottest denim brands: plays up the sex appeal of her Current/Elliott star-print jeans with a tight top and stilettos, while dresses hers down with an oversize military jacket and trendy flat sandals.
29 of 45
HEIDI VS. MINKA
Heidi and Minka prove that the best way to style a bright striped maxi is, well, simply. The and the Friday Night Lights star wear their Alternative Apparel maxi skirts with similar black tanks (Heidi’s is Holmes & Yang) and gold chains.
30 of 45
JESSICA VS. BEYONCé
Two hot celeb moms, two totally different styles: the lets her bright Carven top peek out of her blazer, while the pairs the zigzag-print piece with equally bold pants.
31 of 45
KOURTNEY VS. LUCY
A pre-pregnancy takes on a Pretty Little Liar star in ruffled Ted Baker. Each puts her own spin on the simple LBD with eye-catching accessories.
32 of 45
VANESSA VS. RACHAEL
This flirty white Pamella Roland number was a perfect pick for these two brunette beauties – though goes for sparkly silver pumps, while Rachael rocks two-tone ankle-strap sandals.
33 of 45
AMANDA VS. ASHLEY
How chic do these look in their skinnies? Gray tops, classic shades and black accessories balance out the look-at-me pants.
34 of 45
MINKA VS. CAT
Two stunning stars who were both thinking pink. The actress works the 3.1 Phillip Lim dress with loose locks and nude pumps; the TV host opts for strappy sandals and a leopard clutch.
35 of 45
LAUREN VS. JESSICA
StyleWatch star showdown! Our and our July go head-to-head in the same printed Heartloom maxi, though Jessica adds some edge via a denim vest and sandals.
36 of 45
AMY VS. KRISTEN
Amy goes sweet in her Joe’s “Gabriella” top with printed jeans and a chain-strap purse, while the of the latest Hollywood scandal gives the tank a rocker spin.
37 of 45
JESSICA VS. OLIVIA
Most girls would sport a neon Rebecca Minkoff statement sweater with basics. Not these two, who add the line’s to busy printed skirts then pile on plenty of eye-catching accessories.
38 of 45
SELITA VS. COLBIE
Who says you have to wear a gown the way it’s sold? Selita wears her BCBG Max Azria dress simply, with silvery accessories, but Colbie decides to turn the sheer overlay into a side-mullet and show off her gams.
39 of 45
DIANNA VS. HOLLAND
Two teen TV stars, two takes on the same pretty Alice + Olivia dress (pre-order the $495 frock ). Dianna’s is polished with an overcoat and navy heels, while Holland’s is girlie with a golden belt and loose locks.
40 of 45
JENNIFER VS. VICTORIA
We’re sure is thrilled whenever a huge celeb like is spotted in one of her dresses. That is, unless the aforementioned star wears it better than the designer herself.
41 of 45
JENNIFER VS. NICOLE
Both stars rocked this Bill Blass skirt-and-top ensemble but with her own unique spin: The actress keeps it prim and proper with a bun and gold heels, while the singer goes ultra-sexy in strappy sandals, golden jewels and a big ol’ updo.
42 of 45
KATIE VS. FREIDA
How cute are these stars in stripes? Both and Freida know a good deal when they see one, picking the same $89.50 Madewell tee in two different colors. We love both looks, but who styled hers best?
43 of 45
SHAY VS. BETH
Two more stars in an affordable find! Both look sunny and sweet in a color-block LOFT dress (sold out online, but still available in some stores for $25!). Shay punches hers up with blue shoes, while Beth sticks to neutral ones.
44 of 45
ALI VS. NATHALIA
Nickelodeon actress Nathalia (right) let her blue Tees by Tina dress get all the attention by forgoing accessories, whereas the former Bachelorette paired the same frock with a turquoise necklace and neon orange heels.
45 of 45
ROONEY VS. ANNE
Two short-haired ladies in edgy roles, two versions of the same dramatic Givenchy by Riccardo Tisci dress. works it in an all-white look, while goes for the more reserved LBD version.
Lady Gaga Returns to Her Wild Style in Cheeky Satin Marc Jacobs Hot Pants
Ireland Baldwin Gets an Early Start on Halloween with a Racy (and Bloody) Costume
Back to Brunette! Demi Lovato Ditches the Blonde After Short-lived Stint
WATCH: Rihanna Teaches Her Niece Majesty How to Do a Manicure