What was originally planned as an intimate gathering quickly turned into a much bigger event as the duo decided to perform a medley of hits together from the deejay booth for the entire club — including classics like “Bye Bye Bye” and “I Want It That Way.”
“Joey was presented with a multi tier cake with a big picture of his head on top, and danced with female fans while sipping on a pricy bottle of Louis XIII,” a source tells PEOPLE of the glitzy bash.
Also at ORA that night, Julio Iglesias Jr., who had a more low key evening sipping mezcal cocktails from ORA’s cocktail bar in the upstairs Anti Social room.
Later that night, Fatone continued the celebration by reserving three massive tables at Ricky’s South Beach, where he kicked back with a group of more than 20 friends. The birthday boy was spotted drinking vodka and Red Bull and at one point got onstage and sang with the live band.
The gang stayed for over three hours before leaving around 2 a.m.