1 of 17
Concept: The ultra-polarizing marshmallow treat meets the Golden Oreo cookie.
Tasting notes: Surprisingly delicious, with only minor points deducted for a slightly bitter aftertaste and, well, not really tasting anything like Peeps. Suspiciously similar to the Strawberry Shortcake flavor, actually. (It should be noted that a select few staffers strongly disagreed with the positive reviews.)
2 of 17
3 of 17
Concept: "Dual wafer" cookies stuffed with a chocolate chip creme. But, hmm ... don't we already have Cookie Dough?
Tasting notes: Crunchy, sweet, creamy — but what exactly is that flavor? If you weren't looking at the package, it'd be tough to tell these are supposed to taste like chocolate chip cookies. But maybe that's because they're actually choco chip — whatever that is.
4 of 17
Concept: Pie-cookie-hybrid (otherwise known as a "pie-brid")
Tasting Notes: We're not positive that pie lends itself to cookie form — it just makes us miss pie crust — but as a cookie, it is yummy. Just don't expect overt blueberry-ness.
5 of 17
Concept: Childhood in a cookie
Tasting Notes: It was only natural that a fruity crisp cookie dipped in milk tasted just as delicious as a fruity cereal soaked in milk. Bravo, Oreo.
6 of 17
Concept: Fresh, fun and flirty
Tasting notes: A scent that would fill the Sistine Chapel accompanied by a delightfully sweet flavor that actually matches the concept.
7 of 17
Concept: Good idea, and at least it's not another riff on a cake flavor
Tasting notes: Chocolatey, yes. Cremey, yes. But filled cupcake-y? It's not quite the Hostess with the mostest.
8 of 17
Concept: On point.
Tasting notes: Decadent, rich, thick, lush
9 of 17
Concept: Whyyyy though?
Tasting Notes: Sweet, cotton-candy-y, cloying
10 of 17
Concept: HELL YES.
Tasting Notes: Indulgent and sweet, but doesn't taste much like red velvet
11 of 17
Concept: We're into it.
Tasting Notes: Very sweet, not much coconut, but lots of vanilla
12 of 17
KEY LIME PIE
Concept: Citrus in an Oreo? I don't know about this.
Tasting notes: Yummy Graham cracker cookie, disconcerting green color, nice/mellow flavor
13 of 17
Concept: Why mess with such a perfect shape?
Tasting notes: Crispy, light, amazing, delicious
14 of 17
Concept: Wait, pumpkin spice is still a thing?
Tasting notes: Sweet, subtle, cinnamon-y, addictive
15 of 17
Concept: DREAMS COME TRUE.
Tasting notes: Chocolatey, caramel-y, complex, but not quite cookie dough-y
16 of 17
Concept: Oh yes.
Tasting notes: Far too sweet…but also delicious
17 of 17
Tasting notes:Yummy – and better than actual s'mores