The burger chain, which started in Manhattan and has since expanded to over 100 locations across the country — and internationally in cities like London, Tokyo and Dubai — is also a favorite of foodie celebrities like Chrissy Teigen and John Legend.
And while 2016 was the year in which the over-the-top milkshakes from Black Tap had their moment, Kelly Ripa and guest host John Leguizamo also chimed in with some more traditional chain restaurant favorites.
For more celebrity food and restaurant news, follow People Food on Facebook.
“White Castle for me. Just so old school,” Leguizamo said. “What about the Wendy’s Frosty?,” Ripa added. “If I’m going to blow the calories, it’s going to be on a Wendy’s Frosty.”
WATCH THIS: Jude Law Shows Off His Talent for Accents
The actor also dished on his recent trip to Goa, India. “If I’m honest, I’ve been to India three times, and I prefer other areas,” he said. “But it’s pretty beautiful. I went there to get away. It’s the first time in eight years I’ve been away without my children. I was like, ‘This is really relaxing.’ I couldn’t believe it. A lot of sleeping, lot of reading. Beautiful beaches, beautiful people — really lovely, friendly people. And great food. I love Indian food.”