We may still be dreaming of rainbow bagels (all night, every night), but this new chocolate-lover’s treat is seriously making it hard to remain faithful to the multi-colored creations taking the internet by storm.
The Bagel Nook in Freehold, New Jersey is changing the breakfast game with its “Overload” bagels, an over-the-top mashup of popular snack foods.
And the most popular item: The Oreo Bagel, a sweet bagel baked with pulverized Oreos right in the dough.
Try to remain calm. It gets better.
The freshly-baked bagel is then split, smothered with a thick layer of Oreo-flavored cream cheese (yes, that’s a mixture of crushed cookies and sweetened cream cheese), and topped with whole Oreo cookies. Because, this is not a time for restraint.
“We make all of these by hand every day,” Alex Berkowitz, who runs The Bagel Nook with his family, tells PEOPLE. “They are so popular.”
The bakery also offers Overload bagel in cereal-flavored mashups like Froot Loops, Fruity Pebbles, Cap’n Crunch and Cocoa Puffs, paired with an overflowing spread and cereal bits smashed inside. And, yes, they also sell the Instagram-famous rainbow bagels too.
WATCH THIS: How to Make a Brownie Bits Milkshake
“It has become a little friendly competition between our family who can come up with the next big thing,” Berkowitz adds.