“We may use Pickle Crunch as a cake topper at our wedding,” Loeb, 38, jokes to PEOPLE.
The entrepreneur, who has his own food line, is often seen toting jars of his latest Crunchy Condiment product to the Emmy awards and Golden Globes while supporting Vergara, 41, and it’s now a “running joke” among friends, he says.
In all seriousness, the couple haven’t finalized details for their big day yet, but are still going strong, splitting time between Los Angeles (where Vergara films Modern Family), New York and Loeb’s home state of Florida.
One of their favorite pastimes is indulging in food, and Loeb often cooks for his fiancée, who “loves to eat,” he says.
“We travel extensively and don’t always get a lot of time to spend at home,” he says. “But when we do, especially with the holidays coming up, we have a lot of our favorite recipes that we make, like green bean casseroles, stuffing and potato dishes.”
One thing’s for sure: we can’t wait to see what they’ll be serving to their guests on their big day!