1 of 9
2 of 9
Few things are sexier than a funny guy, and this year especially, Key has been the one tickling our funny bone.
3 of 9
Ever since The Office, he's been the not-so-secret crush of many a woman, though it's his utter and complete adoration of his wife Emily Blunt and their two daughters — plus his talent and good looks — that land him on the list.
4 of 9
5 of 9
Mr. Robot's breakout star (and Emmy winner) tells PEOPLE he thinks some women likely find him sexy because of his television character, though we're more interested in the man himself.
6 of 9
You've seen that shirtless selfie. You've heard the lyrics to his songs. The youngest of the dearly departed Jonas Brothers made 2016 (and 2015, for that matter) his own, and the world noticed.
7 of 9
He shaved his eyebrows for his role in Suicide Squad, telling PEOPLE of the move that "doing things that scare you is often times the thing that's right for you." That fearlessness is sexy.
8 of 9
9 of 9
Though he jokes to PEOPLE that it was his mom who nominated him for the issue, we can assure The Daily Show host that it's forward-thinking fans who did it —and who are tuning in regularly to hear him talk politics and beyond.
Tracy Morgan, Beyoncé, Justin Bieber and More Stars Hit Up All-Star Weekend in L.A. — See the Pics
Jennifer Lawrence, David Beckham & More Stars Discuss What It's Really Like to Attend a Celebrity Wedding
Grab a Box of Tissues: All the Celebrity Breakups of 2018 — So Far
13 Celebs Reveal How They Knew Their Significant Other Was The One
New Year, New Love! The Hottest Celeb Couples of 2018 — So Far