1 of 9
2 of 9
3 of 9
Someone's having a good time! Baby Daddy's Chelsea Kane, costar Derek Theler and The Goldbergs' Hayley Orrantia – who documented her whole night out on PEOPLE's Instagram – have a ball while hanging out.
4 of 9
THE HOT SEAT
Staring contest? Silly face faceoff? Fake fight? Whatever it is, Samberg and co-honoree Anna Faris only have eyes for each other while taking five at the PEOPLE and Essie fête.
5 of 9
Another of PEOPLE's Ones to Watch, Fruitvale Station's Michael B. Jordan, snaps a shot with costar Ahna O'Reilly – before snapping another for our Instagram.
6 of 9
Trophy Wife's Bailee Madison and Disney darling Debby Ryan catch up over candy and manis near the party's Essie photo booth.
7 of 9
8 of 9
HOT IN HOLLYWOOD
Fast friends? Bleu links up with The Vampire Diaries's Kat Graham, singer Jesse McCartney and Madison during their night out.
9 of 9
A LEAGUE OF THEIR OWN
The League costars (and real-life loves) Mark Duplass and Katie Aselton buddy up with Scandal's Bellamy Young, who spent her night mingling with party-goers and taking shots in the Essie photo booth.
Jared Leto, Julianne Moore & More Celebs Who Say They Can't Watch Themselves on Screen
Why Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet Make the Perfect Date — and 5 Questions We’d Want to Ask
Lamar Odom Was 'Surprised' to See Khloé Kardashian at His Bedside After 'All the S— I Had Done' Before Overdose