1 of 8
2 of 8
3 of 8
4 of 8
5 of 8
The Bounty Hunter costars' flirtation seems to play out when the cameras aren't rolling: They are spotted hand-in-hand (and with the Scottish actor's hand on her backside) as the two promote their film in 2009. "I literally became a member of her family," Butler told PEOPLE of their relationship a year later.
6 of 8
First linked in 2009 when they costarred in He's Just Not That Into You, talk of an Aniston-Cooper romance reignites after the actor's 2011 split from longtime girlfriend Renée Zellweger. "Jen always had a soft spot for Bradley, and she thinks he is very attractive and charming," a source tells PEOPLE, but soon after, Aniston steps out with Justin Theroux.
7 of 8
It was total puppy love for Aniston and her beloved Welsh corgi-terrier mix, who died in 2011 at age 15. "He's my baby boy. Norman goes with me on location – I've got to take Norman," she told PEOPLE of the most enduring steady in her life. She later debuts an inked commemoration for her furry friend.
8 of 8
People Who Work in Bowling Alleys Reveal 16 Things You Might Not Know
How Taylor and Ed Hid from the Cops, and More Epic Party Stories As Told By Your Favorite Stars
Shadowhunters Star Matthew Daddario Dishes on His Boys Night Out with Costar Alberto Rosende
FULL EPISODE | People Now Wednesday January 18, 2017
Kim Zolciak-Biermann and Daughter Brielle Are All About the Faux Fur in Adorable Throwback